Inman Connect is relocating from Las Vegas to San Diego in 2025 and promises to be bigger, better, and bolder than ever. Join us for Inman Connect San Diego on July 30-Aug. 1, 2025, where the brightest minds in real estate will come together to shape the future of the industry. Secure your spot today for an exclusive discount.
In 2012, at the age of 28, I decided to open my own real estate brokerage as the country was recovering from a major recession. I rented a stylish storefront office in Downtown Orlando, and today, Mainframe Real Estate is one of Central Florida’s top brokerages. When asked why I opened my own brokerage, I admit I was young and naive.
I’ve advised many on opening their own brokerages and typically dissuade them from doing so. Opening a brokerage may seem like a natural progression in a successful real estate career. However, it’s often a significant step backward. Here’s why.
Choosing the Wrong Motivation
There are two primary reasons individuals may want to open a brokerage. Either they are naive, underestimating the complexities involved, or they are driven by ego, wanting complete control and autonomy. The desire to make more money often falls under the category of being naive.
Thinking that owning a brokerage means being your own boss is another naive assumption. In reality, you become accountable to every agent you hire. Each agent brings new demands, making it challenging to keep everyone satisfied. Ultimately, as a business owner, you answer to more people than ever before, with the needs of others taking priority.
Mastering the Unprecedented
Opening a business creates a complex and demanding entity that can drain your resources and time. Tasks multiply rapidly, and as the business expands, so do the challenges. To succeed, you must become well-versed in all aspects of the business, from operations to marketing to technology.
If you’re set on opening a brokerage, my counterintuitive advice is to start small. Avoid hiring agents or establishing a large office, as these can lead to significant expenses and challenges. Instead, focus on building a solid foundation before scaling up.
Managing Agent Dynamics
Recruiting agents and maintaining a positive office culture are essential tasks for a broker. Convincing agents to join and stay with your brokerage can be a long and challenging process. As a broker, you’ll find yourself navigating various personalities and managing egos, requiring skills in diplomacy and empathy.
Losing a loyal agent can be emotionally difficult, highlighting the unpredictable nature of the industry. As a broker, you must be prepared to handle the highs and lows of agent turnover while maintaining a cohesive team.
Going Big, or Going Home
When it comes to opening a brokerage, you can either start small, go big, or reconsider your decision. Competing against established industry giants from day one is a daunting task, requiring a clear value proposition and strategic approach. Consider the challenges ahead and define your end goal before embarking on this journey.
Commission compression is a reality in the real estate brokerage industry, with many firms competing on price. To stand out, you’ll need a unique selling point and a solid plan for growth and sustainability.
In the realm of real estate brokerages, the competition is fierce. If a brokerage is not cost-effective, it must offer exceptional value to stand out. Conversely, if it is inexpensive, it requires a high number of agents and transactions to stay afloat. In this cutthroat environment, brokers are constantly vying for business in a market flooded with budget-friendly models, leading to a race to the bottom.
When considering your long-term goals, it’s important to acknowledge the shifting landscape of mergers and acquisitions within the real estate industry. Rather than acquiring entire companies, larger brokerages are now focused on poaching their competitors’ top agents through lucrative sign-on bonuses. The days of buying out competitors are dwindling, as companies opt to dismantle their rivals instead.
While the real estate industry has yet to experience a disruptive force akin to Amazon or Netflix, the traditional market could face rapid devastation if such a game-changer emerges. As a brokerage owner looking towards a lucrative exit strategy, the uncertainty of growth timelines and potential industry upheaval may give rise to apprehension about the future viability of your business.
Success in the brokerage world is not guaranteed, with many ventures ending in dysfunction or stagnation. While there are instances of single-agent brokerages thriving, the competitive landscape demands more sophisticated strategies. Team-based brokerages, while promising, require extensive support systems and infrastructure that cannot be built overnight.
In defining success, simplicity is key. Achieving a work-life balance while generating the desired income is the ultimate goal. Launching a brokerage is a challenging and winding journey towards this version of success, prompting consideration of alternative avenues such as scaling a real estate sales business, investing in properties for passive income, or pursuing other passions beyond traditional brokerage duties.
Despite the pragmatic outlook on the brokerage industry, there are no regrets in the pursuit of entrepreneurial endeavors. Building a brokerage with top-tier agents and proprietary technology has been rewarding, providing a creative outlet amidst the challenges of the market. While the path to success is arduous, learning from the missteps of others is invaluable in making informed career decisions with lasting impacts.
While the odds may seem stacked against aspiring brokerage owners, there is always room for exception. Perhaps you possess the talent, drive, and resilience to outshine competitors, build a profitable brokerage, and maintain a fulfilling work-life balance. Before taking the plunge, reflect on whether your ambitions are grounded in reality or if a hint of naivety colors your aspirations.
Sean Frank, the visionary behind Mainframe Real Estate in Florida, shares his insights on the dynamic world of real estate brokerage. Connect with him on Instagram and LinkedIn for more industry perspectives and entrepreneurial wisdom. The sentence is already clear and does not need to be rewritten.